Bioshock Mafia (Town Win)

[Kazekirimaru]

That's a reason WHY people claim but not a reason for me to claim

Hm. This doesn't sound like a claim.

Actually GR, why aren't you voting me?

Neither does this.


Let's kill it.

[Captain Murphy]

Lets lynch LMD, I aint got time for this shit. Not claiming on top of everything else has sealed it for me

[Mcdonalds]

Not claiming on top of everything else has sealed it for me

Wait a minute, why do you give a shit, you said you were lynching me regardless?

[Mcdonalds]

Let's kill it.

I'll be getting the last laugh with this one buddy .

[Captain Murphy]

Not claiming on top of everything else has sealed it for me

Wait a minute, why do you give a shit, you said you were lynching me regardless?

Its disgusting that you wont claim, I was telling others just to lynch you because its a piss take not claiming and making a big fuss

[Mcdonalds]

Wait a minute, you have more of a problem with me not claiming (which you have stated that wouldn't change what you do regardless) and not that 2-3 people have admitted I am scum, and aren't voting me and that one is voting Scumbag for 'reasons', and that someone is honestly pushing a case against someone that is likely town.

Boy am I going to enjoy this.

Btw, since you people won't do anything (Hey guys there is a reason)

---

I am Anna Culpepper, I have a passive that lets me continue to post if I am lynched, I cannot vote however

[Captain Murphy]

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

[Mcdonalds]

Do you believe it?

[Mcdonalds]

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

Wasn't I the best lynch option anyways?

[Captain Murphy]

Do you believe it?

Yes

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

Wasn't I the best lynch option anyways?

Yes, it just makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside that the lynch isn't on someone claiming doc or some other important town role

[Mcdonalds]

Do you believe it?

Yes

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

Wasn't I the best lynch option
anyways?

Yes, it just makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside that the lynch isn't on someone claiming doc or some other important town role

you either reached the same conclusion stardust and I did, or your scum.

We'll find out tomorrow I guess .

[Kazekirimaru]

My guess is if LMD is scum he'll WIFOM now and claim a weak PR because after saying this scum would claim a powerful PR to avoid lynch(for at least a day.)

Still holding my breath.

[Kazekirimaru]

Did some reading. Anna Culpepper is a musician? So...a radio personality.

This claim kinda makes sense.

Ehhhh...

[Yannaria]

yeah I'm convinced vote lord mcdonalds

[Captain Murphy]

The name is real but the ability could be fake, he hasn't even provided flavor paraphrase either.

On top if that IF he flips town (I think its highly unlikely) he can still post and help the town

[imopen2]

Why would scum have that ability?

[Yannaria]

his claim is essentially a tree stump
http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Tree_Stump

so if we lynch LMD and he was town, he is essentially confirmed town and he can comment.
if he's scum, then he's probably lying about that ability, if he's not, he'll just try and throw us off all game and we can ignore him

[Stardust]

Unvote.

I am Anna Culpepper, I have a passive that lets me continue to post if I am lynched, I cannot vote however

Can you continue to post if you're nightkilled too? Why did you think this was important information to withhold?

Also, full claim, please. I want your full role name. Paraphrase the flavour info while you're at it.

Do you believe it?

Yes

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

Wasn't I the best lynch option anyways?

Yes, it just makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside that the lynch isn't on someone claiming doc or some other important town role

This quote looks like you believe LMD is town. You're feeling good about lynching town? Lynching town is the best lynch option?

yeah I'm convinced vote lord mcdonalds

What convinced you, Yanni?

[Captain Murphy]

Why would scum have that ability?

I didn't say that, I said he is faking (falseclaiming)

[Stardust]

Why would scum have that ability?

I didn't say that, I said he is faking (falseclaiming)

He asked if you believed his claim. You said yes.

[Captain Murphy]

I don't believe he is town but I'm also a realistic person who knows he could flip town and had been incredibly scummy thus far (he has) instead of actually cracking under pressure.

What I'm saying is we have a claim of a cop, a watcher and a tree stump. Would you prefer to make someone else run up a claim day 1? LMD has played scummy and his non co-operation with claim for a long time is the nail in coffin for me.

I am merely saying there is a silver lining in the possibility of a town flip: a townie who can comment but not vote, and won't help us win in numbers but at least he can pressure and scum hunt.

[Captain Murphy]

Why would scum have that ability?

I didn't say that, I said he is faking (falseclaiming)

He asked if you believed his claim. You said yes.

When I said "Yes" to believing "it" I meant I believe:

that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

[Captain Murphy]

I don't believe the claim

[imopen2]

I think you misinterpreted LMD's post then but w/e. I'm not voting him

[Stardust]

Yeah, okay. Just wanted to make sure that got sorted since it seemed pretty off.

Vote: Lord_McDonalds.

I think you misinterpreted LMD's post then but w/e. I'm not voting him

You're currently voting for rezombad. You still think he's the better choice?

How does everyone feel about these groups for imopen to cop? Choose one of the three at random.

If LMD flips town: Scumbag, GR, Yanni
If LMD flips scum: Scumbag, GR, Kaze

[imopen2]

Yeah, okay. Just wanted to make sure that got sorted since it seemed pretty off.

Vote: Lord_McDonalds.

I think you misinterpreted LMD's post then but w/e. I'm not voting him

You're currently voting for rezombad. You still think he's the better choice?

How does everyone feel about these groups for imopen to cop? Choose one of the three at random.

If LMD flips town: Scumbag, GR, Yanni
If LMD flips scum: Scumbag, GR, Kaze

I like those choices better but I still think you should be on the list instead of scumbag. I think everyone is blowing his no lynch vote out of proportion and I'd rather know who you are since you are a stronger player.

Yes, I
still have Rezombad as my number 1 scum suspect. Just because everyone else wants to mislynch LMD doesn't mean I need to... I'm sure you guys will get your last vote from someone else

[TubeHunter]

Alright. T/S list

Witchunt: Town. I don't think someone would falseclaim watcher, and has generally seemed town in his posts.
CM: Town, (strongest vibe at that). We need some leadership, and like the way his votes are going
Suga: Null. I feel Like he needs to post more.(Funny coming from me I know) I have no serious problems with his stances atm
Imopen: lean Town. I'm willing to give the benifit of the doubt to him as of now. Some of his posts raise my eyebrows a bit, but claiming cop leaves him town for now in my eyes.
LMD/Kaze: I believe one is scum. Kaze has been strange with his posts, and a little contradictive (uses OMGUS as a reason for a vote while disregarding the fact he has used it himselft this game) but that might just be his style. I think LMD is the better choice for scum right now. He seems to be deflecting hard on to anyone else, and his post hasn’t been sitting well with me. Also seems to be
cracking
Red/Dust: Strange. Red's posts seemed very scum to me, but now that Stardust has taken over, he feels a lot more town to me. I don’t think I can ever trust him after last game though . Leaning Town
Scumbag: Null. His apparent hatred of day 1 seems to cloud his reads. He gets a free pass from me day 1, but that’s it.
Yanni: Leaning scum to me. He seems to be jumping to every wagon with no reason at all. Although I was looking at the boondocks, and he was doing the same thing there too..
Rezmo: Scum. His continued stance on Imopen smells funny to me. And he wanted Imopen, who he thinks is scum, to investigate him?

After all of this, I think that LMD is the correct lynch for the day. He is generally uncooperative, and if he actully is a Stump, he can still help us scumhunt. Also will tell us alot about Kaze and his alignment. If LMD is town, I feel fairly convinced that Kaze is scum and vice versa.

Vote: Lord Mc_Donalds

[rezombad]

Lmd hasnt done anything to help the town. All hes done is yell at kaze. I asked for more reads from him, but we got "kaze = scum, everyone else = null" even though we have 700 posts. I think hes avoiding giving more reads because he doesnt want to incriminate scumbuddies.

[Yannaria]

Unvote.

I am Anna Culpepper, I have a passive that lets me continue to post if I am lynched, I cannot vote however

Can you continue to post if you're nightkilled too? Why did you think this was important information to withhold?

Also, full claim, please. I want your full role name. Paraphrase the flavour info while you're at it.

Do
you believe it?

Yes

The reason they aren't voting you is because you are at L-2, and that claim seems like you are the best lynch option today

Wasn't I the best lynch option anyways?

Yes, it just makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside that the lynch isn't on someone claiming doc or some other important town role

This quote looks like you believe LMD is town. You're feeling good about lynching town? Lynching town is the best lynch option?

yeah I'm convinced vote lord mcdonalds

What convinced you, Yanni?

I said I was going to vote him if he didn't claim, he made a semiclaim, so I voted him to keep good on my promise

[Yannaria]

Alright. T/S list

Witchunt: Town. I don't think someone would falseclaim watcher, and has generally seemed town in his posts.
CM: Town, (strongest vibe at that). We need some leadership, and like the way his votes are going
Suga: Null. I feel Like he needs to post more.(Funny coming from me I know) I have no serious problems with his stances atm
Imopen: lean Town. I'm willing to give the benifit of the doubt to him as of now. Some of his posts raise my eyebrows a bit, but claiming cop leaves him town for now in my eyes.
LMD/Kaze: I believe one is scum. Kaze has been strange with his posts, and a little contradictive (uses OMGUS as a reason for a vote while disregarding the fact he has used it himselft this game) but that might just be his style. I think LMD
is the better choice for scum right now. He seems to be deflecting hard on to anyone else, and his post hasn’t been sitting well with me. Also seems to be cracking
Red/Dust: Strange. Red's posts seemed very scum to me, but now that Stardust has taken over, he feels a lot more town to me. I don’t think I can ever trust him after last game though . Leaning Town
Scumbag: Null. His apparent hatred of day 1 seems to cloud his reads. He gets a free pass from me day 1, but that’s it.
Yanni: Leaning scum to me. He seems to be jumping to every wagon with no reason at all. Although I was looking at the boondocks, and he was doing the same thing there too..
Rezmo: Scum. His continued stance on Imopen smells funny to me. And he wanted Imopen, who he thinks is scum, to investigate him?

After all of this, I think that LMD is the correct lynch for the day. He is generally uncooperative, and if he actully is a Stump, he can still help us scumhunt. Also will tell us alot about Kaze and his alignment. If LMD is
town, I feel fairly convinced that Kaze is scum and vice versa.

Vote: Lord Mc_Donalds

no reason, ha.

[Captain Murphy]

I think thats a lynch

[Stardust]

If LMD flips town: Scumbag, GR, Yanni
If LMD flips scum: Scumbag, GR, Kaze

I like those choices better but I still think you should be on the list instead of scumbag. I think everyone is blowing his no lynch vote out of proportion and I'd rather know who you are since you are a stronger player.

Yes, I still have Rezombad as my number 1 scum suspect. Just because everyone else wants to mislynch LMD doesn't mean I need to... I'm sure you guys will get your last vote from someone else[/
quote]
I agree with you regarding the No Lynch thing, but Scumbag's still null and an okay choice for copping. He also had a high number of points in my tally, and I didn't want to deviate too far from the consensus idea (I believe Suga is town and should therefore be taken off - I can't say the same for Scumbag). But anyway, I'd actually be happier with your proposal anyway. I'm also a fine choice for copping, especially since my predecessor was acting a little strange, and I'd happily take confirmed town status this game. It would hurt the scum more than most.

But we need to get this figured ASAP!!! imopen still has a lot of people who think he's scum, so he needs a list to stick to. What are people's thoughts on switching Scumbag out for Stardust in the three?



TubeHunter!
- You forgot GR.
- If LMD flips town, Kaze is not necessarily scum. It's just likely. This is a false dichotomy.
- If you can't trust me and my predecessor was "very scum&
quot;, why am I leaning town?

[( G_R )]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

If there is a doctor (one who can actually help people, not like GR PhD thing) you should consider targeting the cop too. Don't tell us, but if WitchHunt gets roleblocked or something, we want the cop to be safe and there needs to be a slight chance that targeting the cop with a NK won't work for scum. GR hope that made sense.

[Col. Khaddafi]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

[imopen2]

How about I just do a random between the choices you gave, plus you? I would rather drop scumbag but we don't have much time till night

[imopen2]

That was directed at stardust btw

[Stardust]

Works for me.

If LMD flips town: Stardust, Scumbag, GR, Yanni
If LMD flips scum: Stardust, Scumbag, GR, Kaze

Ideally, if you're a vig, don't shoot someone on imopen's list. We don't want scumimopen to be able to say "Oh shoot, I targeted the dead guy!"

[imopen2]

I guess scumbag isn't te worst target because even tho I think people are overreacting towards him, if he was confirmed town, it would get people focused on other people. Right now he is a prime mislynch target if he is town

[imopen2]

Cool. Let's do this (hopefully I survive the night)

[Captain Murphy]

Well D1's over, Scumbag should be happy.

If there is a doctor (one who can actually help people, not like GR PhD thing) you should consider targeting the cop too. Don't tell us, but if WitchHunt gets roleblocked or something, we want the cop to be safe and there needs to be a slight chance that targeting the cop with a NK won't work for scum. GR hope that made sense.

No, the doc is protecting our watcher