Dies to Removal

Ok, iso has reviewed my set-up and you can update it in the OP.

It will be a 14-player Normal

oh god I should bring back the official list of demands

When should I expect my game to run?

oh god I should bring back the official list of demands

When should I expect my game to run?

the what?

also, we should probably figure out how many games are going to be going at once.

I'd prefer no more than 2-3 but that's just my opinion.

My set-up has been reviewed and will be a 13 player game.

Kay.

I'll start putting asterisk by reviewed games or something of the sort.

So, so far only imopen2 and Suga have gotten reviews unless I'm missing some person(s) in this thread.

TOLoD was a fantastic tSpy thread that got a lot of red text in it.

I technically reviewed my game, so...

Do we have a consensus on how to review, by the way?

Normal games I generally review for normalcy then balance(if requested)

Non-normal/bastard games I review for balance if requested(but who requests balance in a bastard game? )

Open setups obviously need not be reviewed.

PEDIT: Kay, Iso. I suppose that counts.

Open setups can still be reviewed

All non-bastard games should at least be glanced at.

Review away, Iso;

2 Mafia Goons
1 Doctor
1 Weak Doctor
1 CPR Doctor
1 Paranoid Doctor
1 Quack Doctor
1 Naive Doctor
1 Nurse

Daystart
Every player who is a Doctor is not told which version they are, and will be revealed as "Doctor"
Doctors who protect only stop a single nightkill
Weak Doctor dies if it targets a Mafia Goon (and isn't protected themself)
CPR Doctor saves their target from a nightkill, but if the player isn't actually targeted for a nightkill, the CPR Doctor kills them instead.
Paranoid Doctor is the functional equivalent of a Jailkeeper
Quack Doctor kills their target instead of protecting them, the functional equivalent of a Vigilante
Naive Doctor does nothing at all
Nurse becomes the role of the first Doctor to die.
Endgame Ruling: Mafia win when they control 50% of the town, regardless of whichever Doctor(s) are still alive.

looks like something straight out of that IRC mafia I used to spam with porn links

Also open setup for Checkbox 2: Try Harder

1 Town Governor/2 Shot Bullet Proof
1 Town Unlynchable Town Doctor
1 Mafia Untargetable Roleblocker
9 SKs

Doctor should also be a watcher.

Docs look fine
Agreed about Doc + Watcher for SK Mafia
Should be titled as a bastard game

Open setups can still be reviewed

All non-bastard games should at least be glanced at.

Known open setups, then.

Put myself down as a reviewer.

Took off Guardman, Manders, kpaca, and Zionite since they kinda don't come around anymore and I don't want PMs sent their way with setups never to be answered. If they come back and express interest, I'll put them back up.

where'd kpaca run off to?

Beats me.

the store

Suga has requested to be bumped down the queue.

Iso's game is next up.

kpaca is back and I'd be happy to review a game is necessary

I'll put you up.

I've seen kpaca sporadically lately but he hasn't so much as popped his head in here as of late so yeah.

Fuck, my game is ages away

If you want CM, we can trade positions.

Dudebroz:

I'd like to play my first game of Mafia, and this looks like the place to sign up.

Should I monitor this thread or PM someone directly?

Dudebroz:

I'd like to play my first game of Mafia, and this looks like the place to sign up.

Should I monitor this thread or PM someone directly?

This is sign ups for hosting a game, but I think you've gleaned that already.

Cool, I signed up in that Ragnarok thread. Thanks

Cool, I signed up in that Ragnarok thread. Thanks

Glad to see more people taking interest!

--

Suga is next in queue. Your game will take off once Checkbox mafia ends, Suga, which I project will take about 3 weeks - a month. Think you'll have time to commit then?

Anyone have a problem with Megiddo from MTGS reviewing my game? He's been working with me on it already. Nearly done, probably 13 players.

Works for me.

He must post here first. Anyone who's scared to post here isn't reviewer eligible.

He must post here first. Anyone who's scared to post here isn't reviewer eligible.

I don't think he doesn't post because he's scared. I get a "just let those guys do what they want" attitude from him. He still misses you, CK.

I guess I should say that my game may need to be reviewed more than most - I've got some strange PR's. I'm happy with where it's at right now though. Should be fun!

I'm excite

I'm excite

Me too. By the way, you may want to start thinking about which God you'd like to play as. This game is going to have public role names, so you can select a character during sign-ups.

You could popcorn draft the names? Kind of like the masks in majoras mask mafia on mtgs.

I'm excite

Me too. By the way, you may want to start thinking about which God you'd like to play as. This game is going to have public role names, so you can select a character during sign-ups.

What is your game about?

The Theros Pantheon. Each player is one of the fifteen Theros Gods (though there will only be thirteen to choose from).

You could popcorn draft the names? Kind of like the masks in majoras mask mafia on mtgs.

I was just going to make it first-dibs in the signup thread. Simple.

I'm excite

Me too. By the way, you may want to start thinking about which God you'd like to play as. This game is going to have public role names, so you can select a character during sign-ups.

Sweet. I've got one in mind

Me too.