Another Dead MTG Board
http://community.ist.utl.pt/
Here's the thing.I'm still waiting for manders to figure out that she should claim.Two things are bothering me right now. I will expand more on that tomorrow, but where the hell is Ximbad?
Here's the thing. You said you could clear yourself and the guardian. If it ends up checking out it will be a huge boon for the town. The two of you seem to be the two most likely lynch targets. If you can clear the two of you we can look elsewhere.Here's the thing.I'm still waiting for manders to figure out that she should claim.Two things are bothering me right now. I will expand more on that tomorrow, but where the hell is Ximbad?
Part of me knows that I probably should.
However, part of me knows that it will only help the scum if I do.
So....I'm at a crossroads here and don't know what to do.
Let me re-read,
and once I've done that, I'll re-evaluate the situation.
That entire post was a supplement to the bigger argument that you stayed off the yanni wagon day one and this doesn't change that. Your cryptic claiming is also complete bullshit.As fas as I know, your case on me consists of me being inconsistent, but you just admitted you were mistaken in your initial reading/deciding.
So, what does your case consist of?
And, it's The Guardian who needs to answer my damn question.
I stayed off the Yanni wagon because I've played enough games with him to know that I can't read him for shit. He always seems scummy.That entire post was a supplement to the bigger argument that you stayed off the yanni wagon day one and this doesn't change that. Your cryptic claiming is also complete bullshit.As fas as I know, your case on me consists of me being inconsistent, but you just admitted you were mistaken in your initial reading/deciding.
So, what does your case consist of?
And, it's The Guardian who needs to answer my damn question.
Yeah, not sure what Manders is missing here.*facepalm
And HOW praytell, would the town EVER get a mafia member to lynch one of their own?
You never posted the ending. How long do you plan to sit on this? Even if it's shitty reasoning, you need to post this /now/.I knew the guardian was at l-2, but I voted anyways. On second thought I decided to unvote so we didn't have to worry about the guardian getting cut off.
That said: vote: the guardian
I'll comment on this once I have responses from other players on the questions I asked.@Jones: Alright you cocky bastard. If your that sure I am scum, put your life where your mouth is: If I flip anything other than mafia, you die tomorrow. Oh, and unvote and hammer this if you don't mind.[/quote:
1fq1ov9v]What is the point of this? Is this intended to be anythig other than a symbolic gesture?
This is where I really start to feel confident about lynching the guardian. Earlier in this post he sets up the dichotomy of kpaca or manders. His only reasoning for picking those two people out is that they are good at mafia. This line of reasoning, while not strong, is extremely convenient if the guardian is scum. If he gets one of the two lynched he can still push for the other's lynching tomorrow. On top of that he compiles a list of possible scum thatAs for the second mafia: I am in between imopen and GR. The former because he really has done very little for himself, barely reading, and not a single original thought, aside from barning the hot wagons at the time. GR on the other hand has done very little work on his own, and his posts read more like a commentator than an actual player. I wouldn't put it pass Ximbad to be scum, but those two are my top picks.
includes everyone. Either he's trying to say that he thinks phantasmo is town, or he doesn't want to contradict himself when he pushes for whatever lynch seems most likely tomorrow.
This is in addition to this post:You can see him leaving his options open here too.Checking in.
I am fine with Ximbad, if no one wants to do Manders. There has been at least two votes thrown at him, and he doesn't even address them, only deciding in his last post to chase KJ.
Unvote MH, Vote Ximbad
He's too noncommittal and his reasoning when he does post it is weak.
I have no idea why people are unvoting the guardian.
However, I'll go ahead and spoil the ending. I'm pretty sure
The Guardian is town and will not be voting for him Today.
Pretty lame attempt to fit in, but by which alignment? HmmmmSeems rather early to be voting for people but what do i know?This ain't no V Tech shit or Columbine
But after bowling, I went home for some damn Adventure Time
Vote Yanni
Vote: Captain Murphy
amidoingthisrite?
Oh, wait, he's dead and was town. Nevermind.Pretty lameSeems rather early to be voting for people but what do i know?This ain't no V Tech shit or Columbine
But after bowling, I went home for some damn Adventure Time
Vote Yanni
Vote: Captain Murphy
amidoingthisrite?
attempt to fit in, but by which alignment? Hmmmm
What was this about, Ximbad?vote:manders
I've got a feeling . . .
RVS vote on scum noted as it COULD be bussing.Vote Yanni
Good riddance.
RVS vote on scum noted as it COULD be bussing.Vote Yanni
Good riddance.
Why did you vote here and not the first time you commented on him, Jones?It's because youre making jokes.It's because I'mIm not sure I like the cut of your jib.Also, I don't hate Yanni, so much as I wish he stopped living.
I am joking, I just miss that old Yanni. The one from Flame Warriors...
white, isn't it?
vote: the guardian
Xander, why are you acting like you've never seen me suggest a soft-claim for the sake of discussion?Hmm,
This community might be on to something about no RVS. Curious to see how the initiation process will play on in future games, but for this game:
Why, Manders, do you want a soft-claim? And after suggesting it, why not go specific with what your idea of a soft claim might be?
How do you justify this reaction, Xander?Vote Manders
nJones seems quite defensive as well. But meh, I haven't played with him in quite a while...
Hesitance to join the Yanni wagon noted.I need to re-read from the beginning. I don't get where this Yanni wagon came from. His defensiveness does raise an eyebrow, but I tend to agree with Col. Khaddafi. In my short experience with the game, people behaving like that have been usually townies playing poorly, and giving away an easy mislynch. Not that his posting after being confronted by PhantomS doesn't look scummy, but I keep that possibility open, for now.
Ximbad, why did you just decide the Yanni wagon wasn't going to go anywhereYou're missing a verb. What do you mean by this?I do find the string of imopen2 posts though...
unvote: yanni; vote Captain Murphy
Yanni wagon seems too thin to go anywhere.
So far I like what teefo has to say, but he hasn't really brought up anything meaty.
Heh, Yanni confirmed this was a terrible post. Noted.god this post bothers the hell out of meYou're missing a verb. What do you mean by this?I do find the string of imopen2 posts though...
unvote: yanni; vote Captain Murphy
Yanni wagon seems too thin to go anywhere.
So far I
like what teefo has to say, but he hasn't really brought up anything meaty.
Attempting to detract from the Yanni wagon? Maaaaaaaaaaaybe.I don't think that being aggressive is scummy, especially on day 1. On the contrary, I assume mafia will try to start the game with a low profile. Sure, experienced players may tap on that, but in that case I will say it's a null tell.
On the other hand, that "tag-team" accusation, to call it that, is making my "spider-sense" tingle.
Vote: imopen2
teef posted bad thoughts about GR. Noted.i am more suspicious of g_r right now because i feel like sinbad is just being weird and voting on people without any thought and i am not sure if he is being scummy or not but it's definitely different.
How do you explain that the two votes you made previous to this were not careful at all, but you voting as soon as you saw something worth voting?I just tend to be careful when voting.So?Fair enough. I failed to factor in that this is your first mafia game.
Unvote
Then he comes out of nowhere with a vote on a non-existent player.unvote
vote:killjoy
His only post was on the first saying he would check-in later.
*bad votes that seem to be done so in order to remove suspicion from Yanni, I might add.Then he comes out of nowhere with a vote on a non-existent player.unvote
vote:killjoy
His only post was on the first saying he would check-in later.
Really, Ximbad? I'm on page 5, and you've done NOTHING noteworthy other than throw bad votes.
Ugh, the more I see of Xander, the more I have no fucking clue what I saw that made me think he was town.Checking in.
I am fine with Ximbad, if no one wants to do Manders. There has been at least two votes thrown at him, and he doesn't even address them, only deciding in his last post to chase KJ.
Unvote MH, Vote Ximbad
