Bioshock Mafia (Town Win)

[rezombad]

is it just imopen and tubehunter to post lists now?

just tubehunter

[rezombad]

I feel better about a Lord maccas or Droppin day 1 lynch tbh

I'm gonna go reread LMD's posts, if I can find good reason for voting him I'll help push it. In the meantime, will you go read all of red's and stardusts posts?

[Kazekirimaru]

Can we just drop the T/S list thing and lynch kaze, he's pretty obviously caught scum.

Where did this come from, exactly?

"Ohai i haven't been around but lynch the obvious wagon plz /barn"

[Kazekirimaru]

If someone could actually outline how I've been harmful to the town I'd appreciate it since I'm 99.9% sure that's a scum-lead smear campaign.

[rezombad]

Yeah, you know what, LMD. 'Kaze is Scum' is not a T/S list.

[Captain Murphy]

I feel better about a Lord maccas or Droppin day 1 lynch tbh

I'm gonna go reread LMD's posts, if I can find good reason for voting him I'll help push it. In the meantime, will you go read all of red's and stardusts posts?

Sure thing

[Mcdonalds]

Can we just drop the T/S list thing and lynch kaze, he's pretty obviously caught scum.

Where did this come from, exactly?

"Ohai i haven't been around but lynch the obvious wagon plz /barn"

Given in the span of (maybe) half a dozen posts, you went from thinking DroppinSuga, Col. and I are scum to Imopen, GR and CM are scum, then proceed to try and deflect attention from yourself to others, yeah that's where it came from, and do so in order of people posting thinking your scum.

Now your focusing on me, the guy who lurks day 1 in pretty much
every mafia game he is involved with.

Tell me why you aren't scum again?

[Mcdonalds]

Yeah, you know what, LMD. 'Kaze is Scum' is not a T/S list.

Okay?

What are you going to do with a T/S list from me, the only sure scum read I had at the time was Kaze (still is) what will me telling you that x may or may not be scum is going to do?

[Mcdonalds]

Hint: Nothing

[rezombad]

A little critical thinking or analysis would be appreciated a T/s list of:

1. Kaze: scum
2-12 everyone else: town

is just a vote.

There are probably 3 scum. maybe 2 or 4 but more than 1. Try to find them.

[( G_R )]

GR like CM's plan. Rather have the cop look into Yannaria though, but Colonel is not a bad choice.

GR was wondering why GR hadn't been called scum as usual. rezombad you have an un-counter-claimed cop in your scum team, and what is that nonsense about GR and RedDust's wagon?

[Mcdonalds]

Try to find them.

---

You still haven't outlined what anyone would benefit from a T/S list from me, again I stated that my only strong scum read was Kaze, riddle me this, what would you do with a list "uh he could be, may not be, not sure", other than yell in frustration at me, if the point of the T/S-list-popcorn-extravaganza, was to outline potential lynch suspects, and you get a list of Scum, dunno, maybe, not sure, no clue, possibly, prolly not, dunno, what does that accomplish, why don't I just tell you who I think is scum and save you the time of reading my vague-incomprehensive
ramblings?

Also, I like how you misrepresent what I said as I thought everyone else was town, I never said that.

[Kazekirimaru]

You still haven't outlined what anyone would benefit from a T/S list from me, again I stated that my only strong scum read was Kaze, riddle me this, what would you do with a list "uh he could be, may not be, not sure", other than yell in frustration at me, if the point of the T/S-list-popcorn-extravaganza, was to outline potential lynch suspects, and you get a list of Scum, dunno, maybe, not sure, no clue, possibly, prolly not, dunno, what does that accomplish, why don't I just tell you who I think is scum and save you the time of reading my vague-incomprehensive ramblings?

Also, I like how you misrepresent what I said as I thought everyone else was town, I never said that.

You mean you do something else other than lurk and
post incomprehensible ramblings? le gasp

Funny. You said earlier that you had a problem with me because I was uncooperative with the town, and now you're being uncooperative. Have you a problem with yourself? You should.

[Mcdonalds]

Define uncooperative, continuing to post after being told by the guy trying to lead the town to stop and then basically telling him you'll do as you please or simply cutting the bullshit and posting who I thought was scum?

[Kazekirimaru]

Uncooperative would be not doing what the town is asking you to do. I'm pretty sure you didn't need me to help you with that, but I did it anyway because I love my fellow humans <3

But yeah, you're being that.

[Kazekirimaru]

Methinks you wish not to post reads because you HAVE no reads since scum need not form any ^^

[Mcdonalds]

I do have reads, I think your scum

You clearly don't because you can't make your mind up on a potential scum team

[Kazekirimaru]

Reads change.

I'm so down on lynching either you or GR today. Yush. Feels good man.

[Kazekirimaru]

Besides, I've had you as a scum read this whole time.

[Mcdonalds]

And why were you not trying to push my lynch earlier, if you've had me as scum the whole time, why were you not just voting me and encouraging everyone else to do so?

[Mcdonalds]

Reads change.

I'm so down on lynching either you or GR today. Yush. Feels good man.

In the span of 6 posts, in the span of people saying you might be scum?

[Kazekirimaru]

And why were you not trying to push my lynch earlier, if you've had me as scum the whole time, why were you not just voting me and encouraging everyone else to do so?

Because I wasn't sure.

Now I'm getting there.

PEDIT: Obviously.

[Kazekirimaru]

This feels so good.

Unvote: GR; Vote: LMD

I'll happily kill this today.

[rezombad]

GR like CM's plan. Rather have the cop look into Yannaria though, but Colonel is not a bad choice.

GR was wondering why GR hadn't been called scum as usual. rezombad you have an un-counter-claimed cop in your scum team, and what is that nonsense about GR and RedDust's wagon?

I would not expect a cop to counter claim day 1. I'm confident in a Rednihilist/Stardust Scum flip.

Unvote: Yannaria

Red did say that he was a noob and noobscum usually do
that kind of thing.

there's this nugget of towncred you can use later. You then direct attention away from the building red wagon. A vote from you here would have put rednihilist into claim range. I dont think you felt confident enough in him so you needed to direct attention away.

---

attention is directed away from your scumbuddy rednihist and onto witchunt.
witchunt claims watcher.
you jump to imopen because 'deja vu'
imopen claims cop.
you say star is town. having never directed a question at him.


Also, of the 3 major wagons, you have only asked questions of witchhunt and imopen. The only thing you've said to imopen is 'what didn't you like about kaze's vote'.
You then vote for him because 'deja vu' AFTER cm appears to criticize imopen2. obvbus.

Also, I don't see red's out of game vote, OMGUS and then explanationless redaction of his vote for kaze as scum setting up red to get early game lynched.

---

Them and Suga, too. And rezombad tapered off. And YOU! Gaea's Regent. You've been posting very little content. What are your reads thusfar?

That's why GR asked for people to post more, because GR hasn't any reads on those and that is no good.

GR think that one or two scum joined the WitchHunt wagon and now that both Kaze and imopen2 are the main wagons none of them have picked up as much steam.
.

(emphasis mine)
Sorry I missed this line before. imopen2 at L-3 is no steam?




---

@LMD Something is better than nothing. If you say I dont like rezom for vote X and y. at least that shows that you are interested in helping the town.

'I think kaze is scum.
I
don't think anything other than kaze is scum.
I might not be reading this game or thinking.. but kaze is scum.
what are you asking me questions for? kaze is the scum
I dont need to know anything other than kaze is scum.'

Personally, I think imopen is scum. I'm not going to try to lynch him again today without a really good reason. I have my reasons for thinking he's scum, but his claim precludes my accusation.

If Kaze said 'im the doc' right now, where would your reads be?

[Mcdonalds]

Besides, I've had you as a scum read this whole time.

And why were you not trying to push my lynch earlier, if you've had me as scum the whole time, why were you not just voting me and encouraging everyone else to do so?

Because I wasn't sure.

Now I'm getting there.

PEDIT: Obviously.

Something about these two posts don't mesh, the first implies that your certain I am
scum based on how it reads, but now your saying you weren't certain, what changed, me calling you scum?

[Mcdonalds]

If Kaze said 'im the doc' right now, where would your reads be?

If I my aunt had a package she'd be my uncle.

It wouldn't change anything, his behavior implies he's scum.

[Mcdonalds]

(btw gr didn't say that)

[imopen2]

GR is very likely scum. Look at imopen2 after you all realize that, btw. He's scum, too.

The wheels on the bus go round and round

[Kazekirimaru]

Besides, I've had you as a scum read this whole time.

And why were you not trying to push my lynch earlier, if you've had me as scum the whole time, why were you not just voting me and encouraging everyone else to do so?

Because I
wasn't sure.

Now I'm getting there.

PEDIT: Obviously.

Something about these two posts don't mesh, the first implies that your certain I am scum based on how it reads, but now your saying you weren't certain, what changed, me calling you scum?

Scum read =/= certain scum.

You're grasping at straws and hilariously so, at that.

[Mcdonalds]

This feels so good.

Unvote: GR; Vote: LMD

I'll happily kill this today.

Enh fuck it

Vote Kazekirimaru

[rezombad]

ooh, watch this:

Am I the only one questioning the fact we decided to end any and all discussion to post T/S lists?

That all being said, my only scum read is kaze (see my prior post as to why), and the rest are null/leaning town.

and even that isn't a very strong one..

prior post.. \/ \/ \/

Is it the ability to replace back into a game?

Also, given we are in a bit of a rut, how do you suggest we proceed?

prior post.. \/ \/
\/

That being said, I suggest we exam that graph a bit, there is a decent shot at least one scum has been on one of the wagons

Maybe all

prior post.. \/ \/ \/

I never claimed to have all the answers

prior post.. \/ \/ \/

Kaze seems like a good start

Will have more when after the part of the day wherein I discuss things with human beings

So
this

Can we just drop the T/S list thing and lynch kaze, he's pretty obviously caught scum.

Makes no sense.coming from you. Give me some content or step up to the gallows.


I guess scumteam isn't gr, imopen, stardust.

vote LMD

@CM: I think Kaze could be bussing lmd here. Not very confident about that, but it seems a possibility to me. What do you think?

[Mcdonalds]

Ladies and Gentlemen, witness rezombad logic.

[Mcdonalds]

You literally missed a post rezombad, literally my only content post (if one could call it that).

You also have twice now misrepresented what I've said.

[Kazekirimaru]

Something about these two posts don't mesh, the first implies that your certain I am scum based on how it reads, but now your saying you weren't certain, what changed, me calling you scum?

Ladies and Gentlemen, witness rezombad logic.

Charming.

Folks, this is the perfect example of noobscum tactics. When unable to adequately defend themselves, inexperienced scum will almost always resort to attempts at discrediting their attackers, as seen here.

[Mcdonalds]

Something about these two posts don't mesh, the first implies that your certain I am scum based on how it reads, but now your saying you weren't certain, what changed, me calling you scum?

Ladies and Gentlemen, witness rezombad logic.

Charming.

Folks, this is the perfect example of noobscum tactics. When unable to adequately defend themselves, inexperienced scum will almost always resort
to attempts at discrediting their attackers, as seen here.

Funny, your doing just that.

[Kazekirimaru]

Keep flailing.

[Mcdonalds]

The difference between the two is this, I am not attempting to prove Rezombad scum (more that he is wrong), here I am attacking you and your trying to prove me wrong/discredit me.

[Mcdonalds]

Keep flailing.

Flailing, how, your last 3 posts have been you going "lol ur scum"

[rezombad]

I see you saying you said things you never said.

I see you not posting any content. In fact, before today 14% of your posts were about the band MUSE.

I see you actively refusing to help the town by not scumhunting and refusing to scumhunt.

I see a lynch for you being a lynch for scum.


pedit: I didn't miss a post, I skipped it and went to the post where you said kaze seems like a good start. I'll quote that post here too. It's not that bad.

. Lord knows we're not getting much of anywhere right now.

Yes I am aware of this, why did you feel the need to
state that I did?

Catching up, took a sabbatical from things for a bit

IE, I forgot I do things other than work and play league.

- I'm with Kaze on this one, I don't think T/S lists are going to give us anymore information than what we already have, that being said, I do need to post more so, here are a few things I've noticed
- I like Rezombad's graph, it's proactive and a decent attempt at trying to find scum
- Claiming seems weird, everyone has powers, I am probably putting too much thought into that, but honestly I'm with Colonel on this one, pressuring until someone claims and then moving on to the next person doesn't seem very pro town.
- I don't have any real Scum reads honestly, I don't like the "vote until claim, then unvote" strategy that some have taken but whether that makes them scum or not, I haven't the faintest clue.

So where did you explain why Kaze is scum as you you claimed to do in post 431?

[rezombad]

I did indicate intially that I had skipped that post but had my 'previous post thing copied and pasted it over every line for emphasis. I apologize for the confusion.