Dies to Removal

Mod, [vote count]

Damn it.

Vote Count

When someone claims, do they have to reveal the entire pm? Do they have to keep the pm in the same format (ie "you" vs "I" etc)? can they lie?

There are a few issues I have with yanni's claim but depending on the answers to these questions they could be inadvertent.

I just started a new job this week and I am only allowed to use my phone during lunch so I had been on here a lot less. I'm definitely reading everything but I'm having trouble formulating opinions

When someone claims, do they have to reveal the entire pm? Do they have to keep the pm in the same format (ie "you" vs "I" etc)? can they lie?

There are a few issues I have with yanni's claim but depending on the answers to these questions they could be inadvertent.

I just started a new job this week and I am only allowed to use my phone during lunch so I had been on here a lot less. I'm definitely reading everything but I'm having trouble formulating opinions

They don't have to reveal anything they don't want to, they don't have to tell the truth, etc etc.

(I assume, can't imagine it working any other way)

Entertaining your hypothesis that I'm scum, you'd rather I had pushed a wagon for actual scum?

Or are you shooting for another easy pick now that you can simply nightkill the town watcher?

I mean, there is no way Yanni is going to be lynched day 1, you seem awfully adept at picking up another quick mislynch.

Possible equation:

Col. Khaddafi+Yanni+x=scum team.

I need to solve for x and work out a proof to make sure I'm right though.

When someone claims, do they have to reveal the entire pm? Do they have to keep the pm in the same format (ie "you" vs "I" etc)? can they lie?

There are a few issues I have with yanni's claim but depending on the answers to these questions they could be inadvertent.

I just started a new job this week and I am only allowed to use my phone during lunch so I had been on here a lot less. I'm definitely reading everything but I'm having trouble formulating opinions

you can't quote role PMs directly or you'll be modkilled. I paraphrased as to not do this.

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

lol noob card
I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a new player.

Entertaining your hypothesis that I'm scum, you'd rather I had pushed a wagon for actual scum?

Or are you shooting for another easy pick now that you can simply nightkill the town watcher?

I mean, there is no way Yanni is going to be lynched day 1, you seem awfully adept at picking up another quick mislynch.

wayyyy to much wifom
finger of scumbaggery: scumbag
still like the ximbad votes as he's been far scum baggier than scumbag.

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

lol noob card
I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a new player.

You're not getting a painfully new read?

Entertaining your hypothesis that I'm scum, you'd rather I had pushed a wagon for actual scum?

I don't understand your question here. Are you asking me for advice on how you should play as scum? Like, I honestly have no idea my brain isn't comprehending.

Or are you shooting for another easy pick now that you can simply nightkill the town watcher?

It has already been stated why this doesn't mean anything.

I mean, there is no way Yanni is going to be lynched day 1, you seem awfully adept at picking up another quick mislynch.

I believe they call this
WIFOM? Or some other stupid generic comment that dismisses what you said. I'm sure Yanni would know. At any rate, you're saying you think I'm scum because I pushed a wagon for somebody who I later believed the claim of but you're not providing reasons why my pursuit was bad? If you're any easy lynch, it's because you read like scum.

No, you look like scum because you acted like "damn, now we aren't getting Yanni lynched, lemme find out another easy target. Oh hey, Khaddafi just posted, why not?".

I'm gonna leave you guys have fun for a minute, then I'm going to reevaluate all that has been posted because there is an awful lot of new info.

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

lol noob card
I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a new player.

You're not getting a painfully new read?

he's obviously read
some mafia theory from his posts as he has some idea what's going on, this may be his first game, but he should ahve come across something that said thou shall not buddy.

So, the read that I'm getting is that N_S stayed off the Yanni wagon because he knew all along he was town despite the fact that Yanni played unreal scummy the entire game.

You know how a player knows another player is town on day one? Because they're scum. That's how. Now he's trying to cast suspicion on those on the Yanni wagon without actively pursuing anybody that voted Yanni. Typical passive-aggressive scum.

Vote: Col. Khaddafi

Which is exactly what I said ages ago that people scoffed at.

Unvote Vote: Col. Khaddafi

So, the read that I'm getting is that N_S stayed off the Yanni wagon because he knew all along he was town despite the fact that Yanni played unreal scummy the entire game.

You know how a player knows another player is town on day one? Because they're scum. That's how. Now he's trying to cast suspicion on those on the Yanni wagon without actively pursuing anybody that voted Yanni. Typical passive-aggressive scum.

Vote: Col. Khaddafi

Which is exactly what I said ages ago that people scoffed at.

Unvote Vote: Col. Khaddafi

You said it well before there was any reason to doubt the Yanni wagon. Girl, don't even.

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

lol noob card
I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and
2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a new player.

You're not getting a painfully new read?

he's obviously read some mafia theory from his posts as he has some idea what's going on, this may be his first game, but he should ahve come across something that said thou shall not buddy.

It's worth noting, sure. Not expressing one's own ideas is a strike but right now I believe the Khadaffi wagon is legit. If he fails to offer his own insights then I'll look at him more. I can't say he's playing much differently than I did during my first game though so yeah.

So, the read that I'm getting is that N_S stayed off the Yanni wagon because he knew all along he was town despite the fact that Yanni played unreal scummy the entire game.

You know how a player knows another player is town on day one? Because they're scum. That's how. Now he's trying to cast suspicion on those on the Yanni wagon without actively pursuing anybody that voted Yanni. Typical passive-aggressive scum.

Vote: Col. Khaddafi

Which is exactly what I said ages ago that people scoffed at.

Unvote Vote: Col. Khaddafi

Shimmy shimmy yah.

Also, for emphasis:

No, you...

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing
what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

lol noob card
I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a new player.

You're not getting a painfully new read?

he's obviously read some mafia theory from his posts as he has some idea what's going on, this may be his first game, but he should ahve come across something that said thou shall not buddy.

It's worth noting, sure. Not expressing one's own ideas is a strike but right now I believe the Khadaffi wagon is legit. If he fails to offer his own insights then I'll look at him more. I can't say he's playing much differently than I did during my first game though so yeah.

To be fair he did draw a FOS from me in my mega post

so Col. K is at 4 votes right now. if he gets 5 does that mean he has to claim?

He doesnt have to but ill laser blast him if he doesnt

6th Vote Count.

Yanni (1)- (G_R),
Ximbad (2)- Col. Khaddafif, The Guardian
Manders (1)- Yanni
The Guardian(1)- Captain Murphy,
Col. Khaddafi(4)- Mogadishu Jones, PhantomS, Checkbox, Manders
PhantomS (1)- Imopen2
Not Voting: teefo, Ximbad,

With 12 alive it is 7 to lynch.

The standing tradition of claims is Lynch threshold (it takes X votes to lynch, in this case seven) minus two (in this case five)

ftr I'd still rather lynch ximbad or manders, I'll look over scumbags posts tonight though

At the risk of making myself look stupid by not reviewing posts, I don't hate a Manders vote as much as I hate a ximbad one.

After a small review, I don't really like either vote.

Mod, I count 11 voters, yet you said 12 is alive. Who is not being counted?

Oh, you forgot imopen2.

Ok I'll bite to see what he claims.

Unvote PhantomS, Vote Col. K

I'm Finn, town cop
I love going into adventures and helping other people. My aspirations at being a great hero make me a moral sheriff in the Land of Ooo, and I'm willing to help and protect innocents.
I am able to investigate a person at night

Way to go PhantomS, you've setback town for good in just one day.

Though I have the feeling I should probably congratulate you on your smart play.

Well either Yanni or Scumbag is scum and I say we test with Yanni.

unvote: vote yanni

Oh wait nvm this is easy, i glossed over Scumbag claim to quick.

I'm Finn, hes lying.

unvote: vote col khaddafi

Oh wait nvm this is easy, i glossed over Scumbag claim to quick.

I'm Finn, hes lying.

unvote: vote col khaddafi

Unvote PhantomS, vote Mogadishu Jones

Dude, youre not finn who are you

Man, you've been playing tag team with PhantomS trying to push for Yanni's lynch, you even threw the ridiculous theory that I'm playing tag team with Yanni.

Now you trying to steal my role, really?

i glossed over Scumbag claim to quick.

Like you don't even remember you are the main protagonist of the game? Come on. I don't know how you expect such a gambit to pan out.

We have our first scum right here guys.

No I know who I am, I didnt bother to read your name.

Why are you still lying?

Suggesting im scum for counter claiming you doesnt even make sense.

Suggesting im scum for counter claiming you doesnt even make sense.

How come it doesn't make sense? You saw that I'm under pressure and you are trying to push for the final blow. At the end of the day you get a cop lynched and then you or one of your scumbuddies gets Yanni nightkilled. Even if people catch up to you on day two its still an awesome trade 2 major town roles vs. 1 scum.