Dies to Removal

InflatablePie

like I have never been so confident that we can win this game and I'm going to be mad if we throw it all away and waste a lynch on a probably town PR I have been the closest to confirmed as town (other than CP duh) and I led a lynch on scum D1 and I am incredibly confident that if the town follows m...

InflatablePie

we're also not lynching CP because he is town

mostly because I'm town tho

InflatablePie

see LMD just claimed VT we lynch rez, bomb the counterwagon to scum to eliminate that WIFOM. We could also bomb someone else by PoE but that's a worse play. so we're not lynching/bombing: me because I'm town CP because I'm town Jack because he's most likely town (also kinda confirmable I guess?) Red...

InflatablePie

1. Stardust 2. RedNihilist 3. Kazekirimaru 4. hamfactorial 5. Dechs Kaison 6. rezombad 7. Wraith223 8. imopen2 9. Lord_Mcdonalds WePick Mafia is simple. When you /in, PM me one role (Cop, Doctor, Roleblocker, Vanilla, etc.) and one alignment (Town, Mafia, Werewolf, Alien, etc.). I will pick one of t...

InflatablePie

*doubt that play (of killing imopen) makes sense otherwise

InflatablePie

I seriously feel like Occam's Razor states we lynch the person who the nightkilled target suspected, because I doubt that play makes sense. Like, I don't think imopen was some sort of PR hunt and there were way townier players on the wagon. If we lynch Rez and he flips town, ham should bomb LMD so w...

InflatablePie

I really don't get why MoJo is a good lynch here.

What's the scum motivation for CM to say "I'm not getting lynched with this role" and for MJ to come in, hammer, and use his action in-thread.

InflatablePie

PM received, I'll throw signups up tomorrowish. Still on V/LA-ish in North Carolina.

InflatablePie

hi I'm here. (b' ')b

Don't see why we're voting Jack, don't see why people are still voting him. Especially considering Wraith is leading the wagon.

InflatablePie

I really don't need to post a list of questions.

p.s. - going to NC for 9ish days starting tomorrow. I'll try to keep up in activity but it will definitely be less than usual for about two weeks.

InflatablePie

I didn't really ask you any questions that need answering, I don't think, but it is a big list of reasons why I think you're scum.

oh I guess that last post has questions.

InflatablePie

Post ??? - vote Wraith because you mentioned a SK Not because of his terrible push on LMD yesterday then switching to rcw last-minute? That's your only reasoning? What happened to red being scum? What happened to LMD being scum? What happened to Jack being scum? What happened to ham being - oh you'...

InflatablePie

Here and here he goes back on LMD, still not explaining himself. This post is funny with an rcw scumflip. And I'd think that the night kill gives you just as much to go on as a mis-lynch. Just look at who the dead guy was most suspicious of. [quote=" rezombad » Mon May 12, 2014 9:57 am ":...

InflatablePie

Post 11 - "Where's the scum motivation from me?" Well, since you asked... I did say earlier I didn't see rezscum because he started a huge fight with ham and dragging yourself into town spotlight isn't always good. However, when most of your case is based on your top scumspect being self-...

InflatablePie

Post 1 - Ham/LMD scum, CM/imopen town. Seems weird or arbitrary, but nothing much of note for the moment. Post 2 / Post 3 - his reasoning for ham being scum is for spamming during RVS, which I think is more of a nulltell. He votes ham for being self-conscious in addition to the previous reasoning, ...

InflatablePie

rez, you should probably post thoughts of your own before addressing my case, since you're all caught up and whatnot. Mostly because I'm aware it's WIFOM and you won't have much to say in defense anyway.

InflatablePie

Before I get into ISOing rez to see if I can find anything more... concrete, here's a quick post. MJ, don't get snarky with me. You should care because I'm town, you're presumably town, and town working together to find scum is helpful. Mafia 101. Hell, Red's post earlier on this page is the reason ...

InflatablePie

ebwop: MJ, again (thought I said this before): Wraith doesn't literally mean I'm a Kingmaker, it was just a figure of speech, he does that a lot.

InflatablePie

MJ, I feel that ham is a bad vote at the moment.

I'll make another longish post tomorrow to explain this, but I do want to get this vote down:
vote rezombad

InflatablePie

unvote The thing I don't get about Jack, Red, is that he switched from LMD to rcw when the wagons were 4:4. I don't get why he'd do that as scum. so I'm town, Red can be town. C_P is duh!town. If Jack is town and Wraith is town Roleblocker and CM/MJ is town... that's an all-town wagon. the thing th...

InflatablePie

fullclaim, now. flavor? unlimited shots? I don't like this. if you're going to claim, you had best fullclaim. especially if you're on the potential chopping block for today. alright so: LMD was counterwagon to scum so he's clear [/quote: 7f3hnez6] Could you explain this? game was stalling with vote...

InflatablePie

besides, with 3 confirmed town on the front end of the wagon, Jack is still in a bad spot for switching onto the fifth vote. scum might be a bit more wary if there's another option still open.

InflatablePie

because he could just lurk back and force a NL, or worse a ML. town is in the same position tomorrow even if Jack is more suspected for it, which is bad for town.

it's not 100% cleared, but I'm trying really hard to PoE this.

InflatablePie

right, Wraith mailed him.

I also missed that Wraith claimed Roleblocker and why the fuck would you RB LMD he was the counterwagon to scum

fullclaim, now. flavor? unlimited shots?

InflatablePie

almost forgot: who else sent mail to imopen btw? I'm too lazy to check back but I know someone did

InflatablePie

if we lynch scum correctly again and the scum kill me off because I'm 2gud, someone please just remember my reads. like I could be wrong but I think trying to eliminate via PoE is a strong strategy at the moment and I'm probably on the right track. there's a few things bugging me still but I think I...

InflatablePie

if Jack was scum he could have stayed on LMD, especially with Wraith eventually voting LMD would have resulted in LMD at L-2. I also forgot he kinda newbtowntelled earlier yesterday, whoops. alright so: LMD was counterwagon to scum so he's clear Jack is clear for switching to a scumwagon Red is also...

InflatablePie

actually it was Jack, not LMD. Lord_Mcdonalds (5): Jack, rezombad, Dechs Kaison, hamfactorial, RedNihilist rcwraspy (3): InflatablePie, Cursed_Pride, imopen2 then Red jumps back on rcw, which I guess he has no reason to do as scum same with Jack actually, hmm. unvote oh and then Wraith jumps on LMD ...

InflatablePie

we could always just lynch Wraith like I think he's town but his push of (LMD?) yesterday was pretty bad with an rcw scumflip. Also, Pie, you still didn't answer the question of why would you want to lynch Red. Regardless of the usefulness of his role, he's still extremely town. - I don't. I named o...

InflatablePie

@Dechs: he's a mail-Watcher, he can only watch who sends mail to who. a much less useful role here. @LMD: gonna note here that we shouldn't read TOO far into NK speculation. it's still WIFOM, even though in my experiences (at least on mafiascum) scum tend to kill off threats (and I don't just mean P...

InflatablePie

someone who's less lazy than me should go back and see who was pushing the other wagon(s) over rcw.

I literally have not read anything this day so yeh.

InflatablePie

rcwraspy (7): InflatablePie, Cursed_Pride, imopen2, RedNihilist, Jack, Wraith223, Mogadishu Jones I'm town CP is town imopen is dead!town Red claimed mail-Watcher Jack is null Wraith is town Moga is town so either we lynch Jack or Red today. vote Jack I am curious as to why imopen died. Tempted to s...

InflatablePie

I received no mail.

I'll analyze the rcw wagon when I have time.

InflatablePie

Probably running something close to this at FNM for a while: [deck] 4x Gnarled Scarhide 4x Rakdos Cackler 4x Tormented Hero 4x Brain Maggot 4x Pain Seer 4x Spiteful Returned 4x Mogis's Marauder 4x Herald of Torment 4x Thoughtseize 2x Ultimate Price 2x Hero's Downfall 20x Swamp Sideboard: 2x Duress 2...

InflatablePie

(eastern)

also *deadline

InflatablePie

I'm here, just wondering why we're ignoring rcw for the most part.

reminder - dedline is 2pm monday.

InflatablePie

"I should have done this earlier", coming right after myself and Dechs dissolve the redwagon. "closer to null", he says. Why aren't we voting this? Good news is Dechs launches Suga's slot into my townpile. Not liking how he's just sheeping his strongest read instead of thinking f...

InflatablePie

@InflateablePie, Do you see any differences is DTRMafia and this game with RCW? He seems to be asking the players for more reads than votes in this game. I don't see any hard evidence as Red has given. So far the wagons I disagree with are HAM with Rez going after really nothing in evidence (he eve...

InflatablePie

not sure if you're being a dick so I'll pretend you're serious: not necessarily. in fact, I'm more aware of doing scummy things when I'm town (and usually point it out).

InflatablePie

Why are you more suspicious of rcw rather than ham, though? ham's self-awareness and attitude towards his lynch/wagon seemed townie. why do you feel like hammering raspy is more urgent than voting ham? already have a solid townread on ham. not-so-much with rcw. @Pie: your vote is on me. Any questio...

Dies to Removal

Search found 428 matches

WePick Mafia - Signups (closed!)