Dies to Removal

PhantomS

T/S lists in Popcorn sounds fine to me.

also wtf scumbag
Seriously?

unvote: Vote Yanni

You are going to need to elaborate on this for very obvious reasons.

PhantomS

Who do you want a T/S list from GR?
Shalako? lol

Not that they would give one, but I'd like to know what PhantomS and Mogadishu think.

Also, WTF with that Col.Khaddafi claim?

Why would you single out two specific players without indicating why?

PhantomS

is legacy really cutting count spells or is lord mcdonalds lying to me/not really knowing what hes talking about? A lot of people are benching 1-4 of their Force of Wills. Card is objectively bad and only contextually good against combo or necessary in decks like RUG that just don't like playing sp...

PhantomS

I know when scum won the round.

Just remember town: First PhantomS, than kpaca

PhantomS

Though you should still respond to any questions I've posited in this post. :shrug: why wasting anymore time, kpaca and PhantomS played their cards well. I'm more than happy to wait for when I flip town post-lynch. It will be enough evidence because people are willing to believe I've made a huge ga...

PhantomS

This is just sad more than anything.

PhantomS

Obviously day 2 you guys lynch Jones or PhantomS, I'd go with PhantomS first since he may have some sort of ability, otherwise he would have been the guy who would have lied instead of kpaca. On the unlikely chance that you're not scum we go for kpaca tomorrow and I don't think there's any question...

PhantomS

Additionally, khaddaffi's play lines up perfectly with what scum would do. Try to get the counterclaimer lynched first so that he gets the most out of the fact that he gon' get lynched anyway. This is so open and shut it's not even funny.

PhantomS

At this point, this day ends with a Khadaffi lynch or a kpaca lynch. It's as simple as that. And with this in mind: Unvote Ximbad, Vote PhantomS We have Khaddafi calling me scum for pushing wagons on two players that played the scummiest? There is no way kpaca would claim to be Finn as mafia because...

PhantomS

Also, for emphasis:

No, you...

PhantomS

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy. lol noob card I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a ne...

PhantomS

So, the read that I'm getting is that N_S stayed off the Yanni wagon because he knew all along he was town despite the fact that Yanni played unreal scummy the entire game. You know how a player knows another player is town on day one? Because they're scum. That's how. Now he's trying to cast suspi...

PhantomS

Entertaining your hypothesis that I'm scum, you'd rather I had pushed a wagon for actual scum? I don't understand your question here. Are you asking me for advice on how you should play as scum? Like, I honestly have no idea my brain isn't comprehending. Or are you shooting for another easy pick no...

PhantomS

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy. lol noob card I'm not saying checkbox is scum. I was implying that he's buddying to you and 2chainz a little too hard for my liking, even for a ne...

PhantomS

So, the read that I'm getting is that N_S stayed off the Yanni wagon because he knew all along he was town despite the fact that Yanni played unreal scummy the entire game. You know how a player knows another player is town on day one? Because they're scum. That's how. Now he's trying to cast suspic...

PhantomS

I guess what I'm trying to say, Yanni, is that you need to play better.

PhantomS

And I don't think checkbox is fishing I think he's just really new jumping on him for doing what you probably did in your first game is probably scummy.

PhantomS

gj guys, we just gave mafia their first nightkill
unvote: vote gaddafi

Still need to review more when I'm not hungover. FtR, I don't hate this vote.

PhantomS

gj guys, we just gave mafia their first nightkill

For the record, all this does is ensue a minigame with any potential doc role or other such potential roles. I also still am behind the wagon up to the claim. The claim is literally the only thing taking me off the wagon.

PhantomS

There is no way that he would claim Jake if he wasn't Jake. He is essentially the protagonist's sidekick. That is way too ballsy. At the risk of gaming the mod, I would make a substantial wager that Jake is town. Assuming that nobody else is going to come forward as Jake I will Unvote: Yanni and tak...

PhantomS

Mod, vote count.

PhantomS

A bit of scummy behavior doesn't make someone scum (Xim) but a lot of bad posts, reasoning's, behavior and over reactions (including being overly defensive) makes guardian the best choice. I find the checkbox post good, and would like to see T/S lists from everyone, but in popcorn order I know what...

PhantomS

PhantomS: I like your early vote for Guardian since he jumped on the Yanni train. I've said above how I like your read of Yanni, though while reading the thread, I must admit that I thought you were a little too insistent on him as well. It seems clear as day now, though, and I admire your early re...

PhantomS

I like the part where Yanni has only made even remotely worthwhile posts (if you can call them that) now that the town has actually picked up on him being scummy. Indignant deflection isn't going to convince anybody that you're town, bro. I've seen enough. Let's Unvote, Vote Yanni . I believe that t...

PhantomS

i recall you stating that you had a desire to make storm a thing in this cube, iirc you said originally youd consider the endeavor a failure if you could not. i know you have done well enabling it somewhat i am wondering if you have tried fitting in suspend cards to push this further, i remember ba...

PhantomS

How is this level of whining helping your case?

PhantomS

Not necessarily true. In an open set-up, going no-lynch without realizing roles can help our investigative role get a free-night most of the time. In this case your right, that no-lynch would be bad, but meh. @Jones: Yanni hasn't changed since the beginning, why is it taking you this long to go aft...

PhantomS

No-lynch is almost always atrocious for the town. It does suck when a townie is lynched but it still generates a lot of information for the town.

PhantomS

Yanni pays no attention to what's happening in thread and doesn't even double-check when told to. He is now defending asking for a claim from a user who is not actually at L-2. Come. On. Guys.

PhantomS

also ximbad needs to claimn

Now that the wagon has gone down from 5 to 4 because I had no idea it got as deep as it did you want him to claim?

Why do you guys not want to kill Yanni seriously.

PhantomS

At the rate this crowd moves, 2/7 is pretty substantial pressure IMO. And I don't mean the rate of posts, I mean the rate of votes.

PhantomS

It's what I get for spending my time ITT when I'm dead tired from work.

PhantomS

So, I thought TG had considerably more votes and Ximbad didn't have quite so many. In hindsight, I should have unvoted Ximbad earlier. I realize the rest of you have so much better things to do, such as bitching about salvation, but aside from CM, can we please focus on this game? Here we see a play...

PhantomS

Checking in. I am fine with Ximbad, if no one wants to do Manders. There has been at least two votes thrown at him, and he doesn't even address them, only deciding in his last post to chase KJ. Unvote MH, Vote Ximbad What... Ugh... Are all of you just scum? I'm not going to vote TG just yet as I'm ...

PhantomS

Mod prod everyone btw

PhantomS

unvote vote:killjoy His only post was on the first saying he would check-in later. So, instead of asking for a prod we're going to vote for some guy that we know literal nothing about? And we're going to do so as part of a chain of vote/unvote because vote wherever just lynch someone? Not to mentio...

PhantomS

You are aware you have another 10 players you can analyze? Why are you tunneling on yanni so much? The most scummy non-Yanni posts are the ones that indiscriminately state that players won't vote for Yanni because he sucks. The problem is that a whole grip of people are thinking that way. I'm not g...

PhantomS

Vote Ximbad then. Also the insistence of PhantomS on Yanni is unsettling. Yanni is just dumb. period. Everything he does up to the final day one votecount is to be discarded Like this? What the hell is this? You are specifically giving Yanni a day one free pass because he is a documented moron? I d...

PhantomS

My question to everybody is then, how many day 1 lynches have you been 100% certain on? I see some people completely crack, but it's super rare. I also really, REALLY hate the "Yanni is just stupid Yanni everybody knows he's useless." argument. Yes, it's true, but if that's what we're goin...

PhantomS

Yanni has done basically nothing and I feel you are just throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks phantom

Also, by this metric, who really has done anything?

Search found 194 matches